QB64 Phoenix Edition
Possible bug? Unable to enter a comma in response to INPUT - Printable Version

+- QB64 Phoenix Edition (https://qb64phoenix.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Chatting and Socializing (https://qb64phoenix.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=11)
+--- Forum: General Discussion (https://qb64phoenix.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=2)
+--- Thread: Possible bug? Unable to enter a comma in response to INPUT (/showthread.php?tid=555)

Possible bug? Unable to enter a comma in response to INPUT - hanness - 06-15-2022

In QB64pe 0.8.2 take a look at this code:

Code: (Select All)
a$ = "This is a string, with a comma"
Input b$

Print a$
Print b$

Notice that the first line simply set a string and that the string contains a comma.
The second line is asking for input from a user. Start typing in a string of characters, and somewhere along the line, try to type a comma. The comma will not be accepted.

When it gets to the print statements, it prints the string of text that includes a comma, so clearly a comma is a valid character in a string. Since a comma is a valid character, an INPUT should allow a user to input a comma as part of the string.

RE: Possible bug? Unable to enter a comma in response to INPUT - DSMan195276 - 06-15-2022

This behavior is correct, it has to do with how `Input` allows entering multiple variables at once (with their values separated by a comma). Because of that, when using `Input` with a string on its own you cannot include a comma in the value. You should use `Line Input` instead, which basically works exactly like you want - it reads an entire line of input text into a single string, with no limitations on commas or etc. being in it.

There is a note about this behavior on the Wiki, it goes into a bit more detail:

https://qb64phoenix.com/qb64wiki/index.php/INPUT

RE: Possible bug? Unable to enter a comma in response to INPUT - hanness - 06-15-2022

Thanks, much appreciated

RE: Possible bug? Unable to enter a comma in response to INPUT - bplus - 06-15-2022

Use Line Input when you want to allow commas. 

BTW Input allows multiple Input because comma!

Code: (Select All)
Input "Give me a number comma another "; a, b
Print a, b

   

RE: Possible bug? Unable to enter a comma in response to INPUT - euklides - 06-17-2022

If commas are needed, use something like this:

Locate 10, 1: b$ = "": Print "Your texte here, (with comma also) : ";
Text: GoSub saiscar: If z$ <> Chr$(13) Then Print z$;: b$ = b$ + z$: GoTo Text
Print: Print: Color 0, 7: Print b$: Color 7, 0
Sleep: End
saiscar: z$ = InKey$: If z$ <> "" Then GoTo saiscar
Sais1: z$ = InKey$: If z$ = "" Then GoTo Sais1
Return